Tags
Dan McNay, Historical novel, Joseph Dwight Strong, Marriage infidelity, Robert Louis Stevenson, Treasure Island
Taken from Book Cover of The Truth About Treasure Island by Dan McNay
Original & doctored photos of Robert Louis Stevenson & Joseph Dwight Strong
Breaking up can get nasty, more so for the rich and famous. How many of us have not only cut former lovers or partners from our lives, but also from our photos?
The literary acclaimed Scottish writer, Robert Louis Stevenson (1850-1894) – who gave us Treasure Island, Kidnapped, and Strange Case of Dr Jekyll & Mr Hyde – was not immune to such behavior. He went even further. He obliterated his one-time friend and step-son-in-law, Joseph Dwight Strong (1853-1899), an American artist, from the Stevenson family history.
What crime had Joseph Strong committed to have deserved such wrath?
Research Resources: The Truth About Treasure Island by Dan McNay (2013)
Book Launch – 19 October 2013 – Los Angeles, California
With the passion and mastery of a literary detective, Dan McNay unearths the truth about the relationship between Joseph Strong and Robert Louis Stevenson. In Dan McNay’s novel, The Truth About Treasure Island, published in October 2013, Joe Strong tells his side of that breakup. The lives of the two men became entwined through their choice in women. Joe was twenty-six years when he married Isobel “Belle” Osbourne, an American art student. The following year, thirty-year-old Louis, as he was called by his family and friends, married Belle’s mother, Fanny Van de Grift Osbourne – a divorcee twelve years his senior with two children, Isobel and Lloyd.
Joseph Dwight Strong – Hawaiians at Rest, Waikiki – Oil on Canvas, c. 1884
Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons
Joe begins his story in 1891, during the final three years of Louis’ life. That year, Joe, Belle, and their ten-year-old son, Austin, move to the Stevenson cocoa plantation in Vailima on the Samoan Island of Upolu. Louis, sickly since childhood with tuberculosis, had finally found some relief in the South Pacific climate.
Except for the financial woes of the artistic life, Joe and Belle enjoy a happy and satisfying marital relationship. But Joe is no saint. On arriving at Vailima, he resumes his illicit affair with a native Samoan Sava dancer who he had met on a previous visit. As his marriage unravels, he must come to terms with his deception and his deepening relationship with his young Samoan lover.
Louis is no innocent bystander. With his fame, wealth, affable personality, and physical frailty, he succeeds in captivating the women around him. His step-daughter Belle is no exception. While her mother is busy managing the plantation and household, Belle becomes Louis’ personal assistant and secretary. So taken up with attending to Louis’ demands, she is rarely available for activities with Joe and Austin. When Belle and Louis are together, Joe becomes an outsider.
Fans of Robert Louis Stevenson may object to me taking Joe Strong’s side in their falling out. They may be right in their assessment of Louis’ character. Perhaps I have fallen victim of Joe’s disarming sincerity and honesty in his account of events leading to the breakup with his wife and the Stevenson family, and the loss of his son. Deceitful married men have a way of winning a woman’s sympathy to their side of the story.
Am I wrong in standing by Joe Strong? Hear his side of the story. Judge for yourself.
* * * * * *
When American author, Dan McNay, is not working at the University of Southern California, he’s busy writing stories, composing songs, painting, or singing and playing his banjo at a local festival or bar in Los Angeles and neighboring cities.
Before the release of his second novel, The Truth About Treasure Island, in October 2013, he published his first novel, It Knows You By No Other Name, in 2007.
History typically being written by the victors, it is perhaps no surprise that Robert Louis, though not a military hero in war, should almost automatically be better thought of. We tend to be more comfortable with good guys and bad guys, than real guys, who have (usually) a combination of strengths and weaknesses. If one reads about Thomas Jefferson just a bit, it is enough to remind us that this great “founding father” was against slavery only as an abstraction, not in the way he lived.
LikeLike
So true, Dr. Stein. We tend to glorify our heroes, overlooking their flaws. This is what makes Dan’s novel so intriguing. In telling the story from the viewpoint of the vanquished, he forces the reader to question the actions and behavior of the victor.
A great read for those who love historical fiction.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Guyanese Online and commented:
Thanks to Rosaliene Bacchus for this enlightening article on Treasure Island.
LikeLike
Cyril, thanks for sharing my blog post about Dan McNay’s novel, The Truth About Treasure Island. Much appreciated, as always.
LikeLike
Enlightened read….will read again later and comment after digestion…
No knee jerk reaction….my grey cells are on “go slow” ….25 years as a union
activist takes its toll….it works better than “strike action”….until a compromise
is negotiated….in political terms “diplomacy” …it works.
Kamptan
LikeLike
A lot more to read but my only comment is personal choice.
Sorry historical ” fiction ” not my forte….as a realist I question most
of what I read…in my search for the truth !
In my circle of friends and family we question historical writings
sometimes from sceptimism to the cynical….
in the effort of its relation to the present….our
critical faculties are very alive as we drift into senile dementure.
PM David Cameron stated publicly…..
We will find a cure for senile dementure by 2025
Is this political ambition or just “promises” “promises” !
I do not dislike the man as an individual but I question his judgement.
His battle is more “within” his own party than the position.
BRITISH politricks 2013 and beyond.
Sorry if I strayed from history to politricks….
Politicians are rewriting history in their decision making faculties.
Politics has everything to do with history…factual or fiction.
Kamptan
LikeLike
“Sorry historical ” fiction ” not my forte….as a realist I question most of what I read…in my search for the truth ! In my circle of friends and family we question historical writings sometimes from sceptimism to the cynical….”
I started reading historical fiction as a young adult after a historian introduced me to the works of Victoria Holt – one of several pen names of the English author, Eleanor Hibbert (1906-1993). Holt’s historical novels brought to life all the dull British history I had studied in high school.
I understand your viewpoint about historical writings. As Dr. Stein pointed out in his comments, history is “typically being written by the victors.” History written by the vanquished is an entirely different story. This is why it’s so important that we read widely. And this is what makes Dan McNay’s historical novel so intriguing to me.
LikeLike
His battle is …..his own party than the “opposition”…
My tablet sometimes think for me….ha ha !!
Kamptan
LikeLike
Read on….we never stop learning….but we forget most of what we consume…..all be it…eventually….also every story… like a coin… has two sides….
We can but read between the lines in discerning the truth.
Good luck in your readings….
Kamptan
LikeLike