Tags
Bahia/Brazil, Brazilian poet Carlos Machado, Misogyny, Patriarchy, Poem “A mulher sem nome” (The woman without a name) by Carlos Machado, Violence against women, Women without a voice

Photo Credit: Kultme, Sourced on Templo Cultural Delfos
My Poetry Corner March 2021 features the poem “The woman without a name” (A mulher sem nome) from the poetry collection Lot’s Wife (A mulher de Ló) by Carlos Machado, a Brazilian poet and journalist. Born in 1951 in Muritiba, Bahia, Northeast Brazil, Machado earned his bachelor’s degree in mechanical engineering at the Federal University of Bahia. He studied journalism at the Faculty of Cásper Libero in São Paulo, where he lived for forty years before returning to his home state of Bahia in 2020. He is the creator and editor of the fortnightly bulletin, poesia.net, in which he promotes contemporary Brazilian poets.
Machado’s poetry collection Lot’s Wife, published in 2018, reflects his deep concern for the condition of women. In support of the feminist movement, he is involved in studying the causes and means of combating the increasing incidents of violence against women in Brazil. The biblical story of Lot’s wife is a story of violence against a woman whose only crime was that of looking back.
For readers unfamiliar with the biblical story told in the Old Testament Book of Genesis, chapter 19, the God of Abraham destroys the towns of Sodom and Gomorrah for their sinful ways. Two angels warn Abraham’s nephew Lot, living in Sodom, of the coming cataclysm. They instruct him to flee with his family and not to look back until they had reached the next town. Only Lot’s wife and two daughters heed the warning. Other members of Lot’s extended family refuse to join them, declaring it fake news. We don’t know why Lot’s wife looks back as they leave Sodom. We know only that her punishment is immediate and severe: She is transformed into a pillar of salt. Silenced.
Machado’s collection of 52 poems focuses on the dilemma of Lot’s wife and the aftermath on her surviving husband and daughters, forcing us to examine anew the plight of the woman who failed to follow a simple directive. The featured poem, “The woman without a name,” is the third poem in the collection. In the opening stanza of the four-stanza poem, the poet asks Lot’s wife: What did you desire / on looking back? Since she was unable to speak in her own defense, we are left with more questions, expressed in the second stanza:
Did you miss your house, nostalgia of the flowers of your orchard or, curious, just wanted to know?
In the poem “The time of the look,” Machado explores other possible reasons for her action: the sound of flames crackling, people screaming, horses neighing, and cocks crowing. But one sound pulls at her heart. [She] thought she heard in the distance, / in one of the last houses of / Sodom, a child’s cry. / At that moment she looked back.
This raises more unanswered questions addressed in the poem “Babies.” Were the babies of Sodom all debauched? // Did they carry evil genes, impure blood? // Did they deserve the sulfurous sentence of the gods? The fate of babies and young children when war and devastation strike plagues us to this day.
Defying the instructions of God’s messengers had dire consequences for Lot’s wife. The poet sums up her condemnation in the third stanza:
Just a gesture – and the merciless curse of the centuries.
The poem “Voice” dares to ask more disquieting questions: Why didn’t they give voice / to Lot’s wife? // Why the summary rite, / without defense? Declares the poet in “Without voice”: Woman without voice / is river without mouth.
In the fourth and final stanza of the featured poem “The woman without a name,” the poet observes:
Neither the scribes of the book nor the doctors of the law – all male and fearful – dared to say your name.
The poet persists in seeking answers in the poem “Hammer”: Only the indictment? / Just the libel? // And the defense? And the hammer / of the inquiry? But, as the poet concludes in “Sodium,” history is not written by the underdog or with their perspective. Woe to you, woman without name, he laments. Woe to the underdog.
In the biblical story of the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, Lot’s wife—a woman who has no identity save that of her relationship to her husband—lives on down through the ages. As Machado concludes in “Sign,” the forty-fifth poem of the collection, she is the salt of the earth; the cry no in the courts of silence; the first female insurgent; and the first syllable of every word of liberation.
On Tuesday, March 16th, in the American State of Georgia, a twenty-one-year-old man fatally shot eight people and injured another at three massage spas. Among the dead were seven women—their lives snatched from them in an instant. What crime had they committed to deserve such summary punishment? On his arrest, unharmed, the killer claimed that he was eliminating the temptation of his sex addiction. The killer was “having a really bad day,” the male police captain announced to the media.
Woe to the women struck dead by a sex addict’s bullet. Woe to the underdog.
Blessed be the men who stand beside women in their struggle to be heard, to be believed.
To read the complete featured poem, “The woman without a name,” in English and its original Portuguese, and to learn more about the work of Carlos Machado, go to my Poetry Corner March 2021.
NOTE: All excerpts of poems are from the collection A mulher do Ló (Lot’s wife) by Carlos Machado, Editora Patuá, São Paulo, Brazil, 2018.
Translations from Portuguese to English by Rosaliene Bacchus.
There’s a lot of discussion in the media at the moment in England where a young woman has been murdered by a policeman. Here’s the story:
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/mar/12/sarah-everard-met-police-officer-wayne-couzens-charged
If you google “Sarah Everard” it will show you the debate raging about how safe women are walking alone. To be honest though, I wouldn’t have gone where she did in the dark, considering it too dangerous, but the problem is clearly a lot bigger than that.
LikeLiked by 4 people
John, thanks for raising the case of Sarah Everard. Very tragic indeed! I learned about her murder through the BBC America news media and plan to address her case in my post on March 28th. When I used to work outside the home here in Los Angeles, I had to leave home in the dark, wait alone at the bus stop, and then walk for ten minutes along a deserted road. I experienced a similar situation in Brazil when returning home from work at night in a neighborhood controlled by gangs. As women, we do what we have to do when working to provide for ourselves and family.
LikeLiked by 2 people
A thorough exploration of a fascinating theme, linked well with the latest mass shooting. This had me thinking about the earlier women writers, e.g. Mrs [Elizabeth] Gaskell who, in Victorian times was just someone’s wife.
LikeLiked by 6 people
So true, Derrick. In British tradition, women today also take their husband’s family name when they marry.
LikeLiked by 2 people
This was something I thought deeply about when I became married – whether to keep my maiden name or take my husband’s. I know in America it is becoming more common for a double-barrelled name but that becomes cumbersome and where does it stop?! With such a Swedish first name I did change my surname, and for the main reason, I never wanted my child to have a different one from mine!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Annika, I retained my married name after our divorce for the same reason: I didn’t want to have a different name from my sons. Brazilian women have double-barrelled names after marriage and it is, indeed, cumbersome.
LikeLiked by 2 people
And I was thinking then the children with double-barrelled name marry and add one more! Maybe I think too much! 😀
LikeLiked by 3 people
Women’s fate seems to be endless, as I also mentioned in my repport about Chinese women and their bened-feet! Many thanks, Rosaliene for this important thought!
LikeLiked by 4 people
Thanks for reading, Martina. Sad to say, women across the world suffer all kinds of indignities to obtain and secure a mate.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I remember as a teenager thinking that the women’s movement would change things. Sadly decades later not a whole lot has changed and the struggle continues.
This is very thought-provoking and deeply sad. Why is equality, respect, and plain human decency going to be a reality? I was just reading an article about how domestic violence has increased in Canada during the pandemic. No doubt it has increased in every nation around the world. We are all Lot’s wife!
Silence in the face of brutality is not an option. Thanks for this.
LikeLiked by 5 people
So true, Carol. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Ours is a life-long struggle that we pass on to future generations of women. Machado, too, came to that conclusion in his final poem of his collection: “We are all Lot’s wife!”
LikeLiked by 2 people
We really are!
LikeLiked by 2 people
The story of Lot, his wife, and his unmarried daughters (who see him as, in effect, the last man on earth) is troubling, as is much else in the Bible. Machado finds the link with our own time. A talented man and insightful man. Thanks, Rosaliene.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Dr. Stein, I’m so glad that you can appreciate Machado’s work. He’s an insightful man, indeed. There’s so much more to his collection that I didn’t share in connection with Lot’s unmarried daughters that is truly troubling, as you’ve noted. I leave it to readers to look anew at the complete biblical story of the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah and the chosen surviving family.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love how you connect several stories and themes, ancient and modern, using Machado’s poetry. I’m reminded that the bible’s god was created by men, and most interpretations of bible stories have been offered by men. It makes me wonder — how would Lot’s wife and the babies have fared in a story written and interpreted by women? Would the messages be different? Thanks for the meditation Rosaliene.
LikeLiked by 5 people
Thanks very much, Kim. Glad that you’ve found my post meditative ❤ Patriarchy has its origin way back in the beginning of ancient civilizations. I would like to believe that the history of our species would've been different if the one and true God of Abraham were a female god. But, who am I to say? The origins and evolution of the gods of men are filled with intrigue and controversies.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve seen news reports from Brazil the last few days. The Covid situation there is terrible. Huge numbers of people are dying. Brazil’s president is bad news.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Neil, the Covid situation in Brazil is, indeed, terrible. The country has now risen to second place worldwide, after the USA, in total number of cases and deaths. Deaths per one million people are USA 1,670 and Brazil 1,371. Bolsonaro refuses to accept responsibility for the continued rise in cases, claiming that he’s being discredited by the opposition, that the data is false. Sounds familiar?
LikeLiked by 2 people
I know the Sodom – Gomorrah story, but this Machado_Poet knows how to make it sound more interesting, now I’m really asking myself if Lot’s wife heard some baby cries, or noise of falling structures, flames, or…? And for the victims of the sex addict, MTSRIP!!
Zet Ar
LikeLiked by 4 people
Zet Ar, Machado does, indeed, make us question the events as recorded in the Bible. There’s far more going on that deserves attention.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for sharing this. This women’s history month has been a wakeup call to not only how far we have to go, but how much the pandemic has impacted women. UN Women UK released a statistic that 97% of women there have been sexually harassed. Also, my alma mater Mills College has announced that they are closing. It’s a real loss because it’s obvious from this month that their work is FAR from done! They announced their closure the day after those women were shot in Atlanta. It’s been overwhelming
LikeLiked by 5 people
It’s indeed a sad state of affairs for women worldwide. These are uncertain times. I expect that other colleges and universities will also close their doors. Stay safe and well.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Thank you 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Lot’s Wife by Machado’ is an admirable book that combines formal rigor and exploration of the many voices of silenced women. It is a great joy to see this poet published in the English language.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Andre, thanks for dropping by 🙂 I’m glad that you’ve enjoyed my post. Over the years, I’ve featured several Brazilian poets on my poetry corner. You can check out the list of featured poets on my author’s website at https://www.rosalienebacchus.com/archives-of-featured-poets-brazil1.html.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for sharing!!… Unfortunately, there are closed minded elements of today’s world societies who still follow some centuries old ideologies, mainly for their own self, and elements of the homo sapien race is not a civilized as they want the universe to believe…. and those elements use “fear” as a weapon… “The saddest aspect of life right now is that science gathers knowledge faster than society gathers wisdom”.( Isaac Asimov)…. 🙂
Until we meet again..
May your troubles be less
Your blessings be more
And nothing but happiness
Come through your door
(Irish Saying)
LikeLiked by 4 people
Dutch, thanks for visiting and sharing your thoughts 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow, I adore this interpretation of that story which I always hated, even as a child, since I thought the “punishment” did not fit the “crime” although now I see it through an even clearer lens, that of misogyny towards women. Those rivers run deeper than deep, I guess. Thanks for sharing the work of this wonderful poet, Rosaliene.
LikeLiked by 4 people
My pleasure, Pam 🙂 Until I read Machado’s poetry collection, I had never considered the misogyny buried deep within this catastrophic biblical event. The stories we tell ourselves really do matter. We have to work at creating new narratives.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Totally agree, Rosaliene, and work to undo the mess of the old narratives!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you for bringing up this perspective. The punishment of Lot’s wife is one of those stories in the Bible that I have been uncomfortable with in the back of my mind and maybe swept it under the rug. Now, taking a closer look, I feel… dare I say, angry? I can imagine myself being curious and looking back. Now, as a Christian, I wonder how to incorporate this heightened awareness into my beliefs. It’s a process. But this I know for sure, I am grateful that a man wrote these poems, and that says something in itself about the voice of women in the world. “Blessed be the men who stand beside women in their struggle to be heard, to be believed.” You have certainly stirred things up for me, Rosaliene.
LikeLiked by 5 people
JoAnna, thanks go to Machado for stirring things up. As I mentioned in my comment to Pam Lazos, he opened my eyes to the misogyny buried deep within the story. We need the voices of men in our struggle since, as women, we continue to be blamed and punished when we become victims of male violence. Just like Lot’s wife.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Rosaliene, thank you for this incredible and detailed introduction to Carlos Machado and wow, his poetry is intense in a quiet and subdued manner. A subject matter that is not easy to tackle and he brings his directness and brevity to the heart of it! Sorry to read about yet another mass shooting and hadn’t seen the ‘reason’ behind it – one cannot really comprehend the mind behind it or the loss of so many innocent lives.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Annika, I’m glad that you’ve enjoyed Machado’s poetry. Your description of his poetry as “intense in a quiet and subdued manner” is spot on. Until we can pass sensible gun control laws here in the USA, we will continue to face this human carnage. The gun rights lobbyists are very powerful. Our lives don’t matter; only their profits from gun sales count.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Rosaliene, it is beyond comprehension to us abroad how strong the gun lobby is and that profit is put before lives. It would be a tragedy if people and country become immune to such atrocities. Will there ever be a change, do you think? I follow the news carefully and at one stage saw hope but a long way to go, I feel.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Annika, change is inevitable; it’s the timing that’s hard to predict.
LikeLiked by 1 person
tx for a brave & important post, Rosaliene
LikeLiked by 2 people
So glad you stopped by, da-AL 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very interesting read, especially as I had heard ” the woman with no name” spoken as an identifier more than 7 years ago and did not fully understand. Is this a common epithet for Lot’s wife?
His poetry is strong.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m glad that you like Machado’s poetry. I don’t know if this is a common epithet for Lot’s wife, but, as Machado’s poem reveals, it speaks volumes about the patriarchal view of women.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have very fond memories of visits to Brazil twice in the 90’s: Rio, Sao Paulo, and Santos. Brazilians are wonderful people: friendly, hospitable, spontaneous and vital. And the Church is missional.
Bless you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Erroll, thanks for dropping by and sharing your thoughts 🙂
LikeLike