Black struggle, Caribbean working class, Crisis in capitalism, Emancipation, Institute of the Black World (IBW), Neo-colonialism, Race and class, Walter Rodney, Walter Rodney Speaks: The Making of an African Intellectual
Walter Rodney (1942-1980)
Photo Credit: Africa World Press
Walter Rodney – historian, Pan-Africanist, social critic, and political theorist – was actively involved in the struggle for freedom of black and progressive peoples worldwide. During the mid-1970s, when blacks debated the relationship between race and class, Walter Rodney observed:
The debate which is going on is the reflection of a profound deep-seated crisis in the capitalist and imperialist system. The fact that this debate simultaneously proceeds within the United States, within circles in Africa, Asia and Latin America, [and] within broad communities of students and intellectuals in Europe…indicates the universalization of a particular ideological debate at this time, and it is a reflection of the real crisis in capitalism and imperialism.
The above and following quotes come from Walter Rodney Speaks: The Making of an African Intellectual, published in 1990. This work represents transcripts of conversations between the Institute of the Black World (IBW) and Rodney during a two-day period, April-May 1975, in Amherst, Massachusetts. The sessions aimed not only to probe the historical contradictions in black struggles and in Black America, but also to review Rodney’s own intellectual and political development.
[Caribbean] people have been operating within the aegis of capitalism for five hundred years, which is longer than the working class in the United States. We have been confronting capital, firstly on the slave plantation, and then subsequently on that same plantation after slavery. It is not quite the same as a European capitalist framework, but the conditions of work are in effect capitalist and class alienating – that’s the important thing. The consciousness which springs from this is quite obviously a class consciousness and has been there for many decades and comes out sporadically in various kinds of revolts… It didn’t take the working class a long time to understand…that neo-colonialism hasn’t meant any real change in their lives.
[I]n Guyana there has been the problem that historically the working class has always been divided mainly because of the manipulation of the planter class. The Indians were introduced into the society specifically to counter and break the development of the black working-class movement that arose in opposition to conditions after the end of slavery. So it is not simply as though Africans and Indians co-existed without any relation one to the other. Economic competition between Africans and Indians was deliberately created within the construct of the old capitalist order.
What do we do with the large number of unemployed? Thirty-three percent of [the Caribbean] population is unemployed. Do we call them “lumpen proletariat” and with all that that implies – that they’re outside the working class, that they are even in some ways anti-social – or should we understand that this is a fundamental part of the development of capitalism in our society? It is part of the thrust of capitalism to keep our working people from even having the right to work.
In Guyana, racial politics persist. CARICOM is dead. Black America faces mass incarceration. Global inequality is entrenched. Social turmoil grows worldwide. Emancipation remains illusive.
While I appreciate that capitalism has its own set of problems, I would be interested to know Mr. Rodney’s alternative prescription of government. I am also a little leery of accepting that one cause and one cause only explains the tragic problems that he is discussing. I am no defender of the 1% — the oligarchic class. I believe it is also true that corruption is in general greater among peoples who live closer to the equator regardless of the continent or race of the people who live there, for which I can offer no explanation. Your article is thought provoking, as always, but I wonder if there is more to explain the current suffering than is to be found in Mr. Rodney’s 1990 commentary. Surely, I have no knowledge of Guyana, have never visited there, and defer to you, Rosaliene.
Rosaliene Bacchus said:
Dr. Stein, by “one cause” I infer that you mean “neo-colonialism.” I suppose it must be difficult to appreciate that the labor and wealth (natural resources) of the rest of the world – with the cooperation of corrupt governments placed into power by the West – are exploited to enrich the developed West.
“I believe it is also true that corruption is in general greater among peoples who live closer to the equator regardless of the continent or race of the people who live there, for which I can offer no explanation.”
I was not aware of the correlation between corruption and equatorial regions. I suppose it would depend upon how one defines “corruption.” Remember that corruption involves two or more parties. Remember, too, that the global economy collapsed in 2008 as a result of a corrupt global financial system controlled by multinational corporations headquartered in the northern temperate zone.
It’s interesting to observe that North America, Western Europe and Australia have the lowest levels of corruption on the Corruption Perceptions Index 2013.
Thank you, Rosaliene. You have sparked my interest in reading more about Mr. Rodney. I appreciate that and your hard won experience and knowledge about the subject.
Reblogged this on Guyanese Online.
You may find African Books Collective Ltd a valuable source of information and literature. https://www.africanbookscollective.com/
Rosaliene Bacchus said:
Thanks for sharing. African Books Collective appears to be the place to go for students, scholars and others interested in Africa.
Thanks for more on Walter Rodney – I’ve been looking forward to these posts.
And I do agree with you about neo-colonialism though I must add that it combiined with capitalism makes an almost unbeatable oppression . Also the Perceptions of Corruption index is a find – I just wish I could have seen the criteria used, the number of people polled, etc. Excellent research, Rose.
Rosaliene Bacchus said:
Thanks, Angela. You can find the information you seek at the following link: